Which critics consistently diverge from consensus? Not who scores low — who scores
differently from everyone else on the same book.
HOW TO READ THIS ▾
Contrarian Index = average absolute difference between a critic's score and the consensus for the same book. Higher = more divergent.
Direction = whether the critic tends to score higher (generous) or lower (harsh) than consensus.
Scatter plot = each dot is a critic. X = their average score. Y = contrarian index. Upper corners = most interesting critics.
Insight: Contrarian critics are often the most valuable — their divergence reveals genuine independent thinking rather than herd behavior.
🤝 Most Aligned with Consensus